Monday, April 2, 2012

When Men Need Mothers

I met Brett through a wet, drunken kiss at a party where he leaned in without apology or explanation.  Then I met his giant head in my hands the night I asked him to be my euchre partner at a bar tournament.  We lost and ended up entangled on my couch.  I hadn’t realized how giant he was before then – his head, his hands, his voice, his feet.
            He drags his giant feet when he walks like he didn’t get enough sleep.  I know when he arrives at the coffee shop in our college library without looking up from my book.  This allows me to ignore him, or at least pretend to ignore him as he talks to everyone he can find except me.  I don’t mind though, because I can finally focus for a moment.  I know where he is and I don’t have to look up from my book to see his six foot stature, dressed in a light colored button up with his brown, leather brief case hanging off his shoulder and a cigarette tucked behind his ear.  He dressed to be approachable, not sexy or mysterious.  I would work in the coffee shop as he found someone to smoke his cigarette with because my mind could rest when he was around.
            Brett and I connected through our alcohol consumption over the summer.  He is best at playing to the cinematic – slightly romantic, mostly horny – party boy.  My competitive nature fueled his here-to-have-a-good-time attitude when it came to drinking.  I could beat him at drinking games like beer pong and flip cup, pick out a playlist on my phone to dance on a table to, and shotgun beers to my hearts content. 
            This connection and our competition with each other transformed over time, which fueled our light romance.  We raced to complete the Monday New York Times crossword puzzles, compared the number of votes for our spots in the student organization we both participate in  (I recently won by a landslide), and we would even argue about which friends would take our side in a fight.  It was childish, our relationship.  The two of us would compete over anything, but it was fun and I wanted it to keep going.
            Our campus was small enough that I could keep track of him without texting him.  We would go to the same parties and events.  When we would get drunk, sometimes I would let him kiss me up against a car or a basement wall and sometimes I’d let him come home with me to sleep in my big soft, off campus bed as opposed to his twin bed in the dorms. 
            He showed up at a campus party at my house halfway though the fall.  He was already very drunk at this point and wasn’t in any state to play drinking games with me.  When he cornered me in the narrow hallway on the first floor he kissed me and asked to go upstairs.  It seemed like he needed a bed more than anything else.  I put him in bed with the intention to spend another hour downstairs and to climb in bed with him later.  Without him at the flip cup table my team won easily.  Even without the competition I still had carefree fun because I knew where he was.  I felt like we were a play family.  I could return to him when I got sleepy.  He was up stairs waiting for me. 
            When people started to leave my house and the party was slowing down, I snuck upstairs.  He was out cold.  I had to push him over to climb in bed.  It’s my bed make room, I thought as I pulled the comforter away from him and closed my eyes.  Just as I was drifting off thinking about my play family and our possible future I heard the squirting of the keg tap.  No, I felt it.  No, Brett was peeing in my bed.  It hit my arm and I sprang out of bed, shocked.  I grabbed a change of cloths and ran down the stairs and into the bathroom.  When the bar of soap helped me reclaim my skin I crept into my housemates room on the first floor.  I lay in her bed and tried to stop thinking about Brett wrapped in my urine soaked comforter, still sound asleep.  I was directly beneath Brett and the piss, one floor below.  It seemed like I was habitually under Brett, under his control, under this spell his cast on me to take care of him.  He was powerful, moving me physically and emotionally, even if I still won our flip cup games.  Now one floor beneath him, I began to ask myself the same questions I would continue to ask for months: Am I the woman that allows a man to urinate on me?
            He left in the morning before I saw him.  As I stripped my bed, down comforter, Tempur-Pedic pillow, mattress pad, I was disgusted and embarrassed.  My first concern was reclaiming my most comfortable belongings as I did with my skin the night before.  A close second concern was Brett’s potential humiliation.  He didn’t pee in my bed on purpose.
            Later in the school year, Brett would drunkenly tell my friend Sasha, that I remind him of his mother.  Brett would sleep with another one of my friends and tell me, “It’s not like I was thinking about you when I did it.”  I would take him to Hobby Lobby, a craft store to buy art supplies for a creative portion to one of my many job applications but also to have a serious conversation about the importance of apologies, reconciliation and forgiveness in relationships.  He would tell me that he loves me three times in one night and I would tell him that I only had sex with him that one time because he told me he wanted to be exclusive.
            Looking back I realized that the urine incident was when I suddenly became Brett’s mother, protecting his pride, defending the fault in his decision and laundering his urine soaked sheets.  I was attracted to his childlike, carefree nature but I was also cleaning up after it.  I never confronted Brett about the urine because I didn’t want to decide what role I would ultimately play in his life.  If I was understanding about the pee, I would claim my perpetual motherhood.  If I teased him, I would be confined to childhood.
            Brett is not the first romance in my life where I have been faced with these options: the child or the mother.  From my limited experience with serious relationships, my understanding is that the modern women is forced to act as both of these characters to a varying degree in order to keep up with the modern man, one resisting responsibilities.  It is assumed that a woman will navigate the carefree/caregiver personality solo and the back and forth between the two roles is innate rather than learned.  I didn’t confront Brett about the urine, which made me feel like a “little bitch,” as a close, male friend once called me.  Although I might be the female dog, Brett was the male.  He peed on my like a dog pees on public property to claim me as his own, making me navigate between his friend, his lover, his mother and his fire hydrant.  

7 comments:

  1. Ellen,
    I really like the humor and despondency you combine here. While on the surface this drunken incident is mainly silly- you question it on a larger role, a process I think, for the most part, is really successful.

    You and Brett met through drinking and it is the drinking that ultimately reveals your biggest problem: that you do not know whether or not to mother this person.

    One thing I would like to see more of is dialogue. I think a more thorough exchange between the two of you would further deepen your characters' traits. How do you talk to Brett when sober? Most of what we get are observations that give the introduction a voyeuristic feel. But when you talk you two are forced to interact in a way that could reveal your basic problems to the reader.

    Your descriptions of Brett are very strong. I have a good sense of his overall demeanor. You tell us near the end that Brett would soon sleep with one of your close friends. I would like to know more about how this affected you. I think by showing us more here, it could illustrate how you truly viewed this person.

    Really great piece.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your character development of Brett is great here: his giantness, his cinematic party boy quality, his inability to win drinking games. You write so cleanly and clearly about that spell he casts on you--how you can rest easy knowing he's around--and I related to that, so those lines really drew me in.

    I feel like I really understood your relationship with Brett after reading this. In describing him and your reactions to/around him, you say a lot about yourself indirectly, an that allows the readers make their own assumptions your personality. So the development of you and him as characters is balanced, which I think is why the piece flows so well, seeing as it's one long story until the last paragraph.

    I'd like to hear more about the point when things between you and Brett began to intensify. You talk about meeting him through this college drinking culture (which continues to play a large role in your relationship with him as you say later in the story), and then you go on to say how you two did crossword puzzles together and were on the same student organization. Since you talk about how you could "keep track of him without texting him" and he would talk to everyone he saw in the coffee shop but you, when did your relationship start to grow beyond the drinking and partying, and into everyday life?

    One last thing: I was a little confused once you finish talking about the peeing incident and went into the aftermath of that night. You write that you wanted to speak to him about forgiveness in relationships--did you guys stay together? But were you ever really together in the first place? Why did you feel like you needed to reconcile?

    This was a lot of fun to read, Ellen!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ellen,

    I really like the concept of your story and the idea of comparing your relationship with Brett to that of a mother taking care of a child. You give the reader a clear picture of him as a carefree, childish guy who needs to be mothered. I enjoyed reading about the trajectory of your relationship, from when you two first met up to the act of him peeing on the bed. Actually, the peeing on the bed scene was really great to read. I think you successfully captured how you felt emotionally when it happened and how your thoughts about Brett changed after that moment.

    While you really captured Brett’s personality really well, I would like to learn a little bit more about your relationship with him in general. Did the peeing incident fundamentally change how you viewed your relationship with Brett, or were there moments that might have caused you to think twice about him before that? I also think you could expand on your last paragraph a little bit to explain more about how you have a history of being stuck in the mother or child role in your previous relationships, and how that ties into the standardized roles that women are supposed to assume. I was really interested in what you had to say about that and would love to know more.

    Great piece,

    Tanj

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ellen,

    Really compelling story. I think that it balanced funny and serious very well. You were able to take a silly situation and put in a larger context of the type of relationships you want to be in and your role as a women in them.

    I also think that your description of Bret is really great. It is easy to picture the giantess of him, which I really like because it has a lot of connotations. It simultaneously depicts him as domineering and as a big, clumsy child. Also the part about keeping track of him is also a very mothering quality that we see surface later in the story.

    I was slightly confused about when the relationship switched from simply competing and drinking to being more intense for you. I would like to read more about how that shift happened (or if it did at all).

    Overall, it was a fun and evokative piece!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Also, I forgot to mention that I really like the title!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Really interesting story. I definitely got a sense of how Brett was to you on the playful surface of his personality. You show clearly that the relationship started as something centered around partying and moved on to something that seemed more serious.

    I'd like to see more description of the transition between these two phases of the relationship. You mention at the end that he said he wanted to be exclusive but that he also slept with one of your friends. Did that happen after the proclamation of exclusivity? Were these events pre or post peeing? I think that would help clarify the point you were at in your relationship when that night occurred.

    You mentioned in your bit about the process that you wanted to tie this to the greater experience of women in society. I actually think you did a really good job of that. You mentioned it at the end, making it clear that you related this situation to a larger societal phenomenon, but you didn't make it so prevalent that you took focus off of the complexity of your experience with Brett.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ellen,

    At the beginning of your piece you talk about how Brett is a “giant.” This theme is clear when you are talking about how you are always aware of his presence, but you don’t come back to this again in the piece. You later talk about always being under Brett. Can you pull both of these themes throughout or is one better to focus on than the other?

    A sense of security while there is still much insecurity seems to be an overall theme here at first, and then you switch toward the way in which you might classify your relationship with Brett. Again I wonder if you could make both themes, which both seem important in your growth as woman, a stronger part of your entire piece.

    Drinking is a large focus in your piece, yet I don’t see this as being your central point. Play up the mother, child, lover, fire hydrant bit earlier. These titles seem very important and are very intriguing!

    I love the way you describe him peeing - “I heard the squirting of the keg tap.” It plays into the many examples you give concerning drinking and drinking games, drunken hook-ups, etc.

    Closing line - the use of “fire hydrant” is a fun way to close the piece.

    Overall I was thoroughly entertained throughout your article Ellen, really great work in making a difficult situation humorous!

    Steph

    ReplyDelete